Last year, at CIFF 33, I saw a film by Johnny To called Sparrow.  I was a bit disappointed in the pacing and overall lack of anything very interesting besides nice set pieces and a few ‘action-y’ moves.  The same goes for the Johnny To produced (but not directed) Accident, which ultimately takes an interesting premise and disappoints on the execution.

Several things you probably expect from Accident are there, though.  For one, the style of Accident feels like a well-produced, modern Hong Kong flick.  There is an undeniable mark of an HK actor who is suave, resourceful, and especially in this case: clever.  Brain, the lead character, is the mastermind of an assassination squad that works without directly killing their targets.  They plot and engage seemingly realistic events which lead to an “accidental” death, or one which is undetectable as a homicide by police investigations.  The second thing you would expect from this interesting premise are elaborate, well-shot scenes or the camera panning through the situation in either slow-mo or rapid fire.  Got it.

If the above paragraph is all you knew about the film, it probably sounds pretty good!  Which is why Accident is so disappointing.  An interesting premise and good camera work doesn’t save the excruciatingly slow pacing during parts of the movie.  For the longest time, we are watching Brain try to figure out how to go after his last target, so obsessed it feels a bit like A Beautiful Mind at times.  There is only slight tension which ultimately leads to an anti-climactic ending.  There is a final twist that I admit I still don’t think I fully get yet, so I will give it the benefit of the doubt.

The accidents themselves are too few and far between.  There are really only two elaborate accidents, and a couple more small ones.  They aren’t ridiculous in size enough to be really fun, but then again you wouldn’t want to them to be too wild and crazy.  These scenes range from intense to not even knowing it’s happening.  The latter is an interesting concept, since the audience is put in the shoes of the victim.  The thriller aspect of Accident is definitely present in a few set-ups, and are genuinely good.  There are just too many lulls in between.

In the end, Accident is an ok movie that may put some to sleep in the middle or last half.  Coming in with expectations only hurts what is otherwise an interesting idea, but it is showing when short, non-explicit sex scenes are the most engaging parts of the middle third of the movie.

Rating – 3 /5

Here are a bunch of mini reviews of things I watched from the festival and since then:

All Around Us (Gururi no Koto) -4/5 (CIFF09)
Great, though quite slow.  A family-drama that leaves many messages about living life and the connections between loved ones, especially a spouse.  Some characters were a bit annoying, though it can’t be helped if art imitates reality.

Surveillance -3/5 (CIFF09)
Not horrible, but could have been much better, in my opinion.  Some twists in the plot, some of which are predictable.  But this is no action movie.  It’s almost all dialogue, and awkward dialogue at that, for the first three-quarters of the film.  Probably would have been better as a short.

Chaser (Chugyeoja) – 5/5 (CIFF09)
Excellent thriller.  Korean movies contain some of the best psycho-killer/ detective movies and this is one of them for sure.  Though not as epic as a Park Chan-wook film, it has great pacting, characters, tone, and is interesting to watch.  Some gory parts.  Worth tracking down.

Sparrow (Man Jeuk) – 2/5 (CIFF09)
Too slow, and too long.  The plot is not interesting enough to make a whole movie out of, though it did hold my attention.  What was there was executed well and had some nice imagery.

White on Rice – 4/5 (CIFF09)
Good feel-good comedy.  You kind of root for the main character, and definitely grow to like his quirks.  You can see a lot of miscommunications that a Japanese-American may come across, and this really hits home if you have some familiarity with a non-native English speaker.  Plot is a bit uninspired, but serviceable for fun.

Meatball Machine – 1/5
After seeing the excellent Machine Girl, and iffy Tokyo Gore Police… I knew that Meatball Machine could go either way.  And it was bad.  Bad in a bad way.  Even for a B-movie, there is nothing really interesting that goes on.  The characters are beyond boring… enough to make a user manual seem a worthwhile use of time.  Gross out moments are not realistic or that gross if you’ve seen either of the mentioned ultra-gore movies.  Unfortunately, I can’t recommend this movie to even gore fans.

Tale of Two Sisters (Korean) – My 2nd viewing – 4/5
Although it’s probably one of the best Korean horror films I’ve seen, the rewatch isn’t that great.  The characters are a little boring and the pacing slow, but the ending and mystery is pretty good.  Although it’s a must see for asian horror fans, you really probably only need to see it once.  Compare with Ju-On, which I can watch many times and still enjoy.